Competitor SEO analysis for small businesses
Look at the businesses that appear when your customers search, learn what they do well, then build something more useful.
Who your search competitors are
Your search competitors aren't always your business rivals. For a search like "how to fix a dripping tap", you're up against DIY retailers and YouTube. For "plumber in Ilkley", you're up against other local plumbers and directories. For "landlord gas safety certificate", you might be up against GOV.UK.
So start with searches, not company names. List your five to ten most important searches and look at who appears for each.
How to look at the results
Search on a phone and a laptop, in a private window, ideally from your area. For each search, note:
- The map results, for local searches. Which three businesses appear?
- The organic results. Which sites are in the top five?
- Other features. AI Overviews, "People also ask", videos, images or shopping results.
- The type of page ranking. Service pages, guides, directories, comparison sites?
Patterns appear quickly. If directories dominate, getting listed on them matters. If guides dominate, a sales page won't compete.
What to compare
Pick two or three competitors who appear most often for your searches. Compare them on a few practical points.
Their pages
- Do they have a separate page for each service?
- How much detail do those pages include: prices, process, FAQs, photos?
- Do they have guides answering common questions?
- How are their pages organised and linked?
Their Business Profile
- Which categories do they use?
- How many reviews do they have, and how recent are they?
- Do they reply to reviews?
- How complete is the profile: photos, services, hours?
Their reputation
- Are they listed on the trade body and regulator registers in your sector?
- Have they been mentioned in local press or industry publications?
- Free tools such as Search Console only show your own links, but third-party tools can give a rough idea of who links to competitors. Treat their figures as estimates.
Their site experience
- Does their site load quickly on a phone?
- Is it easy to get in touch?
What not to copy
Competitor research is about understanding what customers expect, not cloning pages. Copying text is a copyright problem and gives Google no reason to prefer you. Copying structure blindly can also copy their mistakes.
Instead, ask: what would make our page more useful than theirs? Usually it's something only you can provide: real prices, real photos, specific local knowledge or a clearer explanation.
Also don't copy tactics that break the rules. If a competitor ranks with a keyword-stuffed business name or fake reviews, it may not last, and you can report clear violations through Google's official routes.
Turning findings into actions
End your analysis with a short list of actions. For example:
1. Create separate pages for the three services where competitors have dedicated pages and we don't. 2. Add pricing guidance to our service pages, as the top two competitors do. 3. Add our Federation of Master Builders membership to our profile and site with a link to verify it. 4. Start asking every customer for a review, since we have far fewer than the businesses in the map. 5. Write a guide on the question that "People also ask" shows for our main service.
Keep it to things you can actually do in the next few months.
A worked example
A new independent optician in Kendal looked at who appeared for "opticians Kendal", "eye test Kendal" and "contact lenses Kendal". Two national chains and one long-established independent took most of the visible places.
The chains had strong brand recognition but generic local pages. The independent had dozens of reviews but an old website with no information on eye test prices or appointment times.
The new optician built pages for eye tests, contact lenses, children's eye care and home visits, with clear prices, NHS eligibility explained and a link to the GOC register for its optometrists. It completed its Business Profile thoroughly and asked every patient for a review. It didn't try to beat the chains on brand. It aimed to be the most useful local option.
How often to repeat it
Search results change. New businesses open, others close, and competitors update their sites. A light review every six months is enough for most small businesses. Repeat it sooner if you see a big drop in visibility for important searches.
Tools that help
- Google Search itself, the most important tool.
- Google Search Console, for your own performance on the same searches.
- Free browser extensions that show Business Profile categories.
- PageSpeed Insights, to compare speed.
- Third-party SEO tools, for estimates of competitors' links and keywords. Useful, but not exact.
Questions
A competitor ranks above me with a worse website. Why?
Rankings depend on many factors, including distance for local searches, reviews, links and history. A plainer site can still rank if it's been around longer, is closer to searchers or has a stronger reputation.
Should I report a competitor breaking the rules?
For clear violations of Google's Business Profile guidelines, such as fake addresses, you can suggest an edit or use the official redressal form. Keep it factual.
Start with a free SEO audit
Your whole site, audited free. No card and no obligation.